Refusing the Right to Bear Arms


My first and only experience with a gun took place when I was eight. My dad gave me a BB gun for a present. I remember shooting at a simple target in the front yard of the home where we lived.

More vividly, I remember the time that a friend was preparing to shoot at the target, and I foolishly passed right in front of him. My friend wasn’t ready to pull the trigger when I passed by, but my dad sternly scolded me. “Never walk in front of someone with a loaded gun,” he said.

Good advice. But I didn’t need it because I never became fond of that gun.

In fact, I’m not fond of guns now — not BB guns, rifles, handguns, or semi-automatics. I never developed any sort of fascination with things that shoot.

I realize this is due to my upbringing. Despite the gift of the BB gun, my father was not really interested in guns either. He didn’t hunt or fish, and so didn’t raise me in that outdoors, survivalist, camo-wearing subculture. Instead, I grew up interested in sports, books, music, films, and urban life.

At some point in my life, I came to the conclusion that gun ownership was actually antithetical to the lifestyle of a Jesus follower. I still believe that.

It is because of that conviction that I don’t own a gun, and never will.

In the midst of the current, post-Newtown national debate on gun control, this is my sole contribution to the discourse. It is my personal pledge, my manifesto.

I don’t own a gun, and never will.

I refuse to claim the rights (whatever they may be) of the Second Amendment. Those rights don’t mean anything to me as a follower of Jesus, who warned us that those who live by the gun, die by the gun.

I’m not that interested in changing the laws either. Yes, I think it’d be great if access to guns were restricted, but wouldn’t it be better if people just began to disarm themselves? Wouldn’t it be better if each of us said to ourselves, “I am not going to own a gun anymore”?

And wouldn’t it be better if, in particular, those who claim to follow Jesus decided to disarm? Imagine the impact if hundreds of thousands of folks said, in unison, “I don’t own a gun, and never will, because I follow the way of Jesus”!

I’m not advocating any sort of forced, government-imposed disarmament, but the free choice of people who are ready to live differently in this gun-loving nation, who are willing to completely divest themselves of weapons in the name of the Prince of Peace.

Why don’t we rise up en masse to refute the words of NRA executive vice president Wayne LaPierre, who foolishly said, “The only way to stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun”? Theologically, this statement is indefensible. Jesus stopped the ultimate “bad guy with a gun” by giving up his life non-violently, and in the process, “destroyed death,” according to the Apostle Paul. The whole truth is that there are lots of ways to stop a bad guy with a gun, and not surprisingly, love is one of the ways.

Furthermore, there is a stark, false dualism at work when we so glibly refer to “bad” and “good” men. How can one really tell the difference, especially when Jesus kept pointing out that those whom his contemporaries thought were “good” were remarkably “bad,” as in the “scribes and Pharisees” who were hypocrites, and that the “bad” deserved compassion and kindness, such as the prostitutes and tax collectors? Guns enforce a black-and-white view of the world, which is extremely gray. And it’s amazing to me how many “good” guys suddenly turn “bad” when they have a gun in their hands.

I can’t think of a more powerful faith statement than to stand in solidarity and say, “Despite the presence of evil and terror in this world, I will not succumb to the false security of owning a gun.”

A word to hunters: Yes, I know that there are many folks who follow Jesus who also like to hunt. I know that your reason for owning guns is recreational. I don’t intend to try to persuade you to give up your guns, nor to insist that there is something morally wrong with hunting. If you hunt, then hunt safely. And keep following Jesus.

A word to those who carry guns which are required by profession: I am aware that there are many folks who follow Jesus who carry guns as part of their job. Again, I have no interest in trying to persuade you to take my pledge. I know that you carry your weapons with a clear conscience. I am not interested in starting an argument. All I ask is that you continue to wrestle with the words of Jesus, in particular, the command to, “Love your enemies.” That’s the best that any of us can do, to continue to struggle with the full import of Jesus’ message. He said some pretty strong things, and commanded us to do some really hard things. None of us are able to live completely and perfectly in the way of Jesus, no matter how hard we try.

However, the person who professes to follow Jesus must grapple with his teachings, as well as the example which he set. It’s clear in my mind that the arc of Jesus’ ministry steers us away from violence in any form, toward peacemaking and acts of radical love. His life also teaches us that violence can never be used to accomplish peace or love; the ends do not justify the means.

I can’t imagine a more powerful witness to the way of Jesus Christ than for as many of us as possible to say proudly, at the top of our voices: I don’t own a gun, and never will.

Who wants to say it with me?



    • mark cagle

      I hope the “bad guys” in your town don’t read this prior to deciding which home to burglarize. How do you think this nation has won wars? By forming a line and just “loving” the enemy into submission?? I think not. You don’t have to have a gun, but an unarmed population is a vulnerable one indeed.

      • wesmagruder

        Mark, this is the risk that we are called to take. And yes, you’ve followed the line of my reasoning well — I oppose all the wars we’ve ever fought. But that’s for another post …

  1. djdfr

    I don’t own a gun and have no plans to do so. Oh, maybe there is hot glue gun somewhere. 🙂
    Have we ever tried living according to Jesus’ teachings? The world would be a different place indeed. We do need a lot more love, “radical love”.

  2. Jerry Berggren


    I think you state as clearly as one can, the right to bear arms is not the same as a duty to bear arms. Many men (and women) have objected to arms, even when they were called to arms by their kings or presidents. Many have died for that position of non-violence.

    Just as I am free to bear arms, you are free to not bear arms.

    If we could apply that logic across all aspects of our society, perhaps the church could find its voice in our society again.

  3. Dawn Anderson

    Wes, I am totally with you. Having lost a husband to suicide by gun and seeing its aftermath in so many families, guns literally make me sick. (As a side note, I also don’t eat meat so I don’t get the whole hunting thing either!) Yes, of course I realize that many people feel like they need guns to protect their families, etc. But I’ll never forget hearing a heartbroken father admit at a suicide support group, “I thought by having the gun in the house I was protecting my family. To my dying day, I will wonder if my son would still be here if a way of ending his life quickly hadn’t been so accessible.” Statistics show a gun in the house is more likely to kill a family member than a criminal. I don’t own a gun and never will!

  4. Roy Taylor

    Wes, I’m curious as to your position on what the correct, Christian response would be for the believer whose house is being broken into and his wife and children about to be raped/murdered by someone. Should that man defend his home?

    BTW, I’m really interested in an exchange of ideas amongst brethren and not an internet argument. I know you are also so just stating my intentions up front. If you don’t see any fruitfulness in the exchange I won’t be offended in the least and respect your opinion and your post.

    • kurtboemler

      When the disciples saw that the authorities had come to arrest Jesus, they attacked with swords. Jesus told them to stop, even knowing that his arrest would lead to his death.

      That’s why I don’t own a gun, and never will. Jesus didn’t want his disciples to take a life to defend his, so I won’t take a life to defend a life. Especially, when I believe that my family, who are also Christians, have eternal life.

  5. pastormack

    Do you own a knife? People get killed with knives all the time. Jesus didn’t want us to carry swords (it is said), and a knife is basically a small sword. Some people think that the only way to cut things (like an onion or a cardboard box) is with a knife, but as followers of Jesus we are called to instantiate his radical love by laying down the knife and finding other, more kingdom-oriented ways to accomplish these ends.

    Knives are used for violence, and violence is always bad, ergo:

    Christians shouldn’t own knives.

    I hope you don’t own a knife, and never will.

  6. Pingback: Refusing the Right to Bear Arms « outtasiteoutamind
  7. Randy

    I am a Christian and I always will be.
    I own a gun and always will.
    I hunt with my guns to eat and it provides for my family.
    If someone kicks my door in and is threatening the life’s of my beautiful family, then yes I will pray…. for a steady hand and an accurate shot. But then and only then would I ever use a gun on something other than my next meal.
    Sounds like you were raised in the city and got your feelings hurt when you were little.
    But anyway good luck to ya now that the world knows you don’t defend yourself, I will be looking for your name in the news paper.

  8. gunowner

    you people are all crazy.
    I own a gun and i plan to use it if i have to, just to protect your sorry hides. wait you can die cause you didn’t protect yourself and i will be living with my head held high, and pistol on my side.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s